Great topic Softy.
I would have to say Heddon's Baby Zara Spooks. Heddon actually brought these back, because i found a couple in the smorgasbord box that Walmart sometimes has.
My Dad and I were going through some old tackle boxes he had in his storage building about three years ago and ran across about a dozen of these baits.
I got them and took all of the hardware off and sent them off for a custom paint job. Once I got them back and got all new hooks, split rings, etc., attached, I was ready to try them out.
Had some good success early last fall on Douglas. Also caught some early summer Boone bass on it as well.
We used to throw these baits years ago on Fontana and Santeelah over in NC.
Another one I would throw in the mix, would be a #11 floating rapala. Deadly in the fall on those mountain lakes.
J